Hello, Internet! Welcome to Game Theory. 90% overthinking Nintendo titles 10% all other companies 100% sick of Five Nights at Freddy’s. Well, at least until October. Nintendo, we need to talk. Year after year, you release new entries in your exclusive franchises, and, in an era where games are more and more cinematic, where the stories they tell are deeper and richer than ever before, you fight against that trend… and HARD. Epic ROM through the ancestral memories of a modern day assassin out to save the world… Plumber want cake! A cross-galaxy quests to save the universe from a long dormant foe, where each choice means the difference between life and death… Squid people play paintball! In fact, Nintendo has stayed SO silent about its characters that it leads many to question whether their games connect at all! And when they DO release timelines, they… Well…They literally make ZERO sense. Or at least they didn’t until today. Because I’m out to prove that gaming’s most famous franchise– One thought to be IMPOSSIBLE to string together Has a timeline that is not only PROVABLE but makes a LOT more sense than most other video game plot lines out there *cough* *cough**cough* I’ve shown you how Rosalina is Luigi’s daughter, and how toad may be a parasitic plague on the kingdom, But now it’s time to figure out how all the Mario games cross over with each other to weave an unexpectedly epic and mind blowing timeline. (Drake) Did somebody say– CROSSOVER? (MatPat) Oh, hey, Drake, Kenny Glad you guys could join me after I so shamelessly name dropped your old show’s title Thanks for coming by and help me put this whole thing together There are a lot games to sort through, so how do we know where to begin? (Drake) Well, clearly it would make the most sense to begin with the games with Mario as a baby, right? That would seem to come before he’s an adult that ventured into the mushroom kingdom (MatPat) But, there are multiple games where he’s a baby. So, let’s refer to this first group of games in the timeline as the “Baby Era.” Which of course starts with Super Mario World 2: Yoshi’s Island Fourteen years after Mario originally appeared in 1981. (Kenny) And you know it’s first because in Yoshi’s Island Baby Bowser sends his magical minion Kamek to kidnap the Mario bros from the stork delivering the boys to their parents. You can’t get much more newborn than stork status– Well, I mean you can, but that’s a lesson for a 6th grade health class not an online video game show. (MatPat) Yep, no time to talk about the birds and bees now, I’ll save that one for your parents. But it IS time to talk storks. At the end of that game Yoshi saves the day, but, as we see in the next game, its direct sequel: Yoshi’s NEW Island, the stork ultimately delivers the Mario brothers to the wrong parents! (Kenny) You just can’t get good help these days (MatPat) Yoshi comes to the rescue, yet AGAIN, solving the Mario mix-up, which leads to Mario and Luigi: Partners in Time, and Yoshi’s Island DS. (Drake) Wait… we JUST started charting this and we’re already dealing with TIME TRAVEL? (MatPat) Well…yeah, actually. In three out of the four games that comprised the “Baby Era,” a future version of Bowser travels to the past To thwart is arch-enemies as CHILDREN. (Drake) I thought you said this was SIMPLER than the Zelda timeline? (MatPat) I said it makes more sense… Nintendo has a habit of making characters travel through time, which, definitely doesn’t make things simpler. You see, the key to sorting out the order of these games lies in the reactions between Baby Bowser, and his future, mature self. In “Partners in Time,” Bowser and Baby Bowser team up for the very first time. However, in Yoshi’s Island DS, the Bowsers don’t seem remotely phased AT ALL by any of these time-travelling shenanigans, leading us to believe that they’ve already crossed paths once before. (Drake) There’s also a line in there where Bowser is calling Baby Bowser: “Past-me.” That’s right! Baby Bowser is NOT Bowser’s son, Bowser Jr. and instead, his past self. (MatPat) Well, that’s a theory for a whole ‘nother day. (Kenny) But what about when future Bowser shows up at the end of Yoshi’s New Island? (Drake) GAH! Kenny! Shhh! (Stage whisper) Spoilers! (MatPat) Can it BE considered a spoiler when it’s SO slapped into the game, the ONLY explanation given is a SPLASH SCREEN that says: “Suddenly…warping through time and space [sic: read space and time]…King Bowser appears!” Seriously, Nintendo? Pretty shamelessly lazy. But, to answer Kenny’s concern: Baby Bowser and Future Bowser DON’T interact with each other at all in that game. Plus, based on the intro cutscene for New Island, we know it’s a direct sequel. Taking place mere minutes after the original Yoshi’s Island. (Kenny) So that gives us a pretty tight timeline thus far. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi’s Island, followed by Yoshi’s NEW Island, Mario and Luigi: Partners in Time –or the past section, at least– and finally ending with Yoshi’s Island DS. What about all the spin-off titles where Baby Mario is around? Like the cart games? (Drake) I think it’s best we focused on the main series’ titles. Yeah, since Nintendo is playing all fast and loose with “WARPING THROUGH SPACE AND TIME.” There’s probably an explanation in there SOMEWHERE for EVERYONE AND THEIR MOM having a baby version now, and being able to cart, and party with them… But again, that’s best addressed in another video. Coming up with a timeline for the main games is tricky enough! (MatPat) And that brings us to the end of our so-called “Baby Era.” Now, it would only make sense to call the next section the “Adult Era.” (Kenny) Man, I was really looking forward to some “Angsty Teenage Era” Mario games. (MatPat) For this we’re gonna have to dig deep into the lore, and leave no stone unturned. Every official source is on the table (Drake) If you take a look at the “Smash History” of the Koopas, you’ll notice the trophy description in Super Smash Brothers Brawl states that the Shellcreepers are, quote, “Shelled enemies in Mario and Luigi faced back when they WERE plumbers.” (MatPat) Exactly. That implies that the Mario Brothers were JUST humble plumbers before they got wrapped up in Mushroom Kingdom heroism. In fact, it actually tells us that they haven’t been plumbers for quite some time. (Kenny) NINTENDO, YOU’VE LIED TO ME! (Drake) That must mean that Mario Brothers and Super Mario Brothers are the next two games in the timeline. As the time that the brothers are plumbers, then they hang up their plungers in favor off edible superpowers… and Peach’s sweet, sweet, cake. YEAH. (Awkward silence and Kenny’s judgmental staring) (MatPat) The true sequel to the NES Super Mario Bros is what we silly Americans know as Mario the Lost Levels. But, believe it or not, this game doesn’t have any of its own story. It was really just a glorified map pack that was packaged as its own standalone game. (Kenny) Sooo…exactly what they did with New Super Luigi U. (Drake) But…that was for the year of Luigi, which makes it slightly better. (MatPat) With that out of the way, the big clue for the next true entry in our Mario timeline lies directly in the manual for Super Mario Brothers 3. In it, we discover that Bowser has seven children, who we’ll start seeing in MANY future installments. What sets Super Mario Brothers 3 as the first game starring the Koopa kids is the only dialogue we ever see them deliver. As you can clearly see, Wendy O. Koopa states: (MatPat as ‘Falsetto’) “This is the first time I’ve met up with Mario, I’m studying his moves very carefully.” (Back to regular MatPat) Geez, that almost sounded like Micky Mouse. (MatPat impersonating Micky) Ha-ha! (Back to regular MatPat) Quality voice-overing, ladies and gentlemen. This clearly means that this is the first time that Mario has ever crossed shells with the Koopalings. And if one manual wasn’t enough, how about two? The manual for Super Mario World clearly states that this game takes place directly after Super Mario Brothers 3. Next up on the chopping block: Super Mario 64. Or rather, its DS retcon: Super Mario 64 DS. In it, King Boo appears and threatens to trap Mario in a painting, Directly foreshadowing the events of Luigi’s Mansion– The next game in the timeline. Following Luigi’s solo adventure, we get Super Mario Sunshine. Oddly enough, what gives away THIS game’s place in the timeline is this super small video feed in the lower right-hand [sic: read left-hand] corner of the screen. When Mario’s new water jet-pack, the F.L.U.D.D. scans Mario to register his identity. In it, we can clearly see the events of the original Super Mario Bros., Super Mario World, and Super Mario 64. So we know it MUST come after all of those. (Drake) That’s all fine and dandy, but what about Super Mario RPG? That’s one of my favorite games ever! (MatPat) Don’t worry! Mario RPG is the next game in the timeline. Wouldn’t you know it? This game features the birth of Yoshi’s love interest: Birdo. (Kenny) Wait… So Yoshi’s been around since Mario was a BABY, and he’s been seen dating a NEWBORN? Man, we’re uncovering some twisted hidden lore. (MatPat) Have you watched any–ANY–of my Mario videos? It’s a REALLY dark franchise. (Drake) Back on track, guys. (MatPat) Oh *laughs* okay. Super Mario RPG inspired a set of spin-off games known as the Mario and Luigi series, starting with Superstar Saga. In it, Birdo makes an appearance, as well as Professor E. Gadd, from Luigi’s Mansion, which is why it has to fall here in the timeline AND I should be sure to mention that Luigi is flat out SHOWN to have the Poltergust 3000 from Luigi’s Mansion. All facts that solidly place these games right here in the timeline. This game also introduces a recurring villain in the Mario and Luigi series: Fawful –It’s “awful” but with an “F”– “Fawful” Fawful also appears in the era spanning sequel, Mario and Luigi: Partners in Time, and even recounts the events of the previous title. This starts a trend in the series where each new installment references the events of the previous titles. Giving us a solid timeline of Mario and Luigi: Bowser’s Inside Story, followed by Mario and Luigi: Dream Team. (Drake) And Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon, comes in after that. In it, Professor E. Gadd outfits Luigi with a brand new Poltergust 5000, to replace the old model that was last seen in Super Stars Saga in Luigi’s Mansion 1. (MatPat) Bringing us into a new age. Well, that is, a new Super Mario Bros. age. With the events of New Super Mario Bros., and New Super Mario Bros. 2 which…dont’t do anything new for the series and instead compound on the tropes and elements introduced in earlier games. But after years, and YEARS of saving the Mushroom Kingdom all by their lonesome In New Super Mario Bros. Wii, and New Super Mario Bros. U, the Mario bros find partners in the form of brand new characters: Blue Toad, and Yellow Toad. (Drake) Gee, Nintendo, REAL original names there, guys. (Kenny) I think they would be better off named something like… “Bucken-Berry” and “Ala-Gold.” (MatPat) With their new Toad friends, we’re brought into the Super Mario Galaxy series, and the first appearance of fan-favorite: Rosalina. Rosalina, who loyal Theorists will know is actually Luigi and Peach’s daughter, comes from the far future. A “Rosalina Era,” if you will. At the end of Super Mario Galaxy, Rosalina uses her Time Travel abilities to retcon the ENTIRE GAME, creating a NEW galaxy. Leading directly into the events of Super Mario Galaxy 2. Let’s be honest here? Galaxy 2 was just the same game, with a fancy new coat of paint. That leads us into Super Mario 3D Land, and Super Mario 3D World. There…isn’t really a definitive way to place these two relative to each other, but we DO know they take place AFTER The New Super Mario Bros., and Super Mario Galaxy games, since they feature a playable Rosalina, those obnoxious cosmic clones from Galaxy, and the Blue Toad, from New Super Mario Bros. Wii, and U. And with that said, for the console Mario games? This is the end of the timeline. One where Peach chooses Luigi over Mario, as we discussed in my two-part video on the subject of Rosalina’s origins, and…that’s it. It’s the end of the story for THOSE two, but MARIO’S story isn’t over. As he hops on over to the GameBoy for the Super Mario Land series. With his younger brother swooping in, and stealing his girl, Mario leaves, pursuing an adventure in the country of Sarasaland. Where the events of the first Super Mario Land take place. Here, Mario saves a NEW princess: Princess Daisy, from an evil alien named Tatanga. How do we know it’s at the end of the timeline? Well, notice the heart. Mario’s affections have moved on to another woman. (Drake) WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT!!! Are we saying that Mario and Luigi’s love lives have been reversed this ENTIRE TIME? That Luigi ends up with Princess Peach, and that Mario ends up with Princess Daisy?! (Kenny) NINTENDO, YOU’VE LIED TO ME! (MatPat) And things finish up with Super Mario Land 2, where, as we read in the manual, Wario’s taken advantage of Mario being in Sarasaland to overtake Mario’s castle. (Kenny) Wait…Mario has a castle? NINTENDO, YOU’VE– (Drake) Kenny! Get a hold of yourself! (MatPat) And there you have it! The complete Mario Timeline. (Kenny) Feels like we’re leaving out a few pretty crucial titles here. (Drake) Hey wait a minute, that’s right! You haven’t covered the original Donkey Kong games. Those were, after all, Mario’s big debut as the carpenter “Jumpman.” In fact, let’s give it a category of its own: “The Jumpman Era.” (Kenny) Which causes a bit of an issue with this timeline, doesn’t it? Mario’s well-established as a PLUMBER. (MatPat) *Laughing” Guys, guys! It WOULD be a problem… Except for the fact that Mario, the carpenter “Jumpman,” and Mario, the plumber Super Mario, Aren’t actually the same PERSON. But rather…drumroll please! (muffled sound of hands tapping on table) (tapping continues) *Sigh* God, can’t get good sound effects anywhere. (tapping stops) But rather, FATHER AND SON! (Kenny and Drake) WHAAAT?! (Gasping sound effect with a pop-up of a shocked famous person) (MatPat, dramatically) Dun, dun, DUUUUNN!! (Back to regular MatPat) See, if can’t get good sound effects, I’ll just do it myself. To prove it, it’s gonna take some monkey business. We have to hop franchises and look for clues sprinkled throughout the Donkey Kong country series. (Kenny) They’re technically gorillas, not monkeys. (MatPat) It’s an expressio–! *exasperated sigh* ah, nevermind By now, everyone knows that the original Donkey Kong, the one climbing girders in the arcade cabinets aged into the surly ape we all know and love, as Cranky Kong. It’s also fairly common knowledge that the current day Donkey Kong, the one with the sporty tie, is actually Cranky’s grandson. Current day Donkey Kong first appeared alongside Baby Mario, as Baby D.K. in Yoshi’s Island DS. Which tells us two things: That Mario and D.K. are about the same age, AND that our current-day D.K. is neither Cranky Kong, NOR Donkey Kong Jr. You know, the who appeared in the original Mariokart, and the one who appeared in Donkey Kong Jr., the game. D.K. Jr., then, is of course, Cranky’s son, making him D.K.’s father. (Drake) But, how can an adult Mario have faced-off against a younger Cranky, and also have been a baby at the same time as the modern-day Donkey Kong? (MatPat) Well, let’s take another look at Cranky, who’s the linchpin in this entire series. Real-world gorillas have a life span of about forty years, and Cranky has got to be on the tail end of that. At full size, Cranky would have been about fifteen: the average age when gorillas stop growing. D.K. Jr. had already been alive for several years, as a gorilla reaches sexual maturity around eight years old. This now presents the possibility that D.K Jr., still a young, and growing ape, would be about the age to be looking for his own mate to sire his son, Donkey Kong III. (Kenny) I never thought that a gorilla’s sexual maturity would be what ties together the entire Mario timeline. (MatPat) Yeah, who knew THAT would be a topic for a video? Laying everything out across Cranky’s lifespan makes one thing abundantly clear: Jupman, the Mario we see in Donkey Kong, and Donkey Kong Jr., is NOT the same person as the Mario we see in the Super Mario series. The sexual maturity of Cranky Kong proves that it can’t be the case. Now get this: Given our established timeframe, it is EXTREMELY likely, that the mother of the Super Mario Brothers, is Paulene. Mario’s damsel in distress from the original Donkey Kong game. The manual for Donkey Kong explicitly refers to her as “Mario’s girlfriend.” That’s MORE confirmation than we’ve ever seen with Peach beyond a kiss and a couple of cakes. We can now actually chart out the entire Mario bloodline, from Jumpman and Paulene to Rosalina. And there you have it! Three Donkey Kong’s, two Mario’s, and one timeline that would make even George Lucas tear his hair out. But hey… That’s just a theory… A GAME THEORY! Thanks for watching! And hey! Now that you’ve learned about the sexual maturity of monkeys– (Kenny) They’re technically gorillas. (MatPat) Why not learn about some stuff NOT primate related, WHILE helping out all of us here at Team Theorist in the process? By checking out lynda.com I’ve mentioned the site before as the place where I first learned how to film and edit when I started the channel, but, since then, I’ve done a bunch more of their video and audio tutorials. Covering everything from the gamification of learning to the foundations of animation. –Well, I just WATCHED the one on animating.– I leave the actual stuff to Ronnie. My best work came out like a mutated stick figure with a bad limb. Anyway! If you like learning online, and want to support the show, type in: L-Y-N-D-A dot com, slash M-A-T-P-A-T Lynda.com/MatPat OR click the link in the description and sign up for a seven day free trial, where you can watch WHATEVER you want, AS MUCH as you want, WHENEVER you want it. Thats a lot of things that you want. So it must be good! Learn everything from how to prepare for the SAT, or how to apply stage makeup, or how to use every tool in Photoshop, OR. ALL. THREE! Be the true Renaissance man you were always born to be. In the words of Captain Planet: The Power is Yours! So have a look and start getting smarter! I mean…*clears throat* You’re already pretty darn smart for choosing to watch Game Theory. Seriously, that was a pretty solid decision that you made, there, but this would be another solid decision! So again: Lynda.com/MatPat Every time a Theorist signs up, an angel gets its wings. Or, more accurately, Ronnie gets one step closer to getting a little window built into the editing basement he’s locked up in. So help Ronnie get some Vitamin D, He could use one of those, too. Your hair is out of control, Ronnie, think of this as an intervention. (fading background music)

Tagged : # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # #

Dennis Veasley

100 thoughts on “Game Theory: The Mario Timeline’s SHOCKING Reveal”

  1. Not to ruin your fun but this is not canon this is not true this is a theory it's a game theory so why are you taking it as fact matpat it doesn't make sense

  2. So if Pauline is in super Mario odyssey then that means it takes place before the new Mario was even born

  3. Sooooooooooooo, the American Super Mario 2 version does not count I take it…….

    Because Birdo was in that.

  4. i just keep coming back to the old videos. i cant remember which video i first saw from you. maybe it was Sonic's speed. idk.

  5. You just ruined your own theory because he was just saying that Mario is evil but in reality that would mean that he’s not

  6. Everyone is saying that Odessy is ruining this video but I didn't see no Super Mario bros. 2 and there is no excuse for not putting that in.

  7. Actually about Luigi and Peach (pretty stupid) BECAUSE:
    1.In other games Luigi still have crush on princess Daisy
    2.In other games mario still have crush on Princess Peach
    3.SUPER MARIO ODYSSEY

  8. 14:18 sooooooooo your Mario is a psychopath is shut down because Mario didn’t try to abuse donkey Kong Jr and didn’t abuse donkey Kong

  9. At the end of super Mario world toad Mario and peach go on vacation doesn’t this mean that super Mario sunshine is directly after Mario world?

  10. So the very first carpenter game-isn't Mario? – but what about the evil Mario theory? You took away some evidence from that!

  11. that is why Pauline is in that game (i forgot the name), he invited his mother and built a toy after her. he must be a "mama's boy"

  12. Technically there are 3 Mario’s! One is Mario the Carpenter the second is Mario the plumber and the third is paper Mario. The evidence of paper mario is shown in Super Mario Paper Jam where an alternate paper world exists In a book from Peach’s castle therefore we can also say that there are two princess toadstools, two Bowsers, two bowser jrs, and a possibility’s of second Luigi. The the second Luigi does not appear in the game, but rather when Paper Mario confuses Luigi as another character. So we can say that theoretically, there are two Luigis as well as three Marios

  13. Wait if rosalia is Luigi,s daughter then that's means on sml uncle Mario is dating rosalia so sml mario is messed up

  14. Typically the Game Boy games Aaron's Canon cuz how's it supposed to be Cannon if it was Mario it was Luigi cuz you think about it Luigi's love is Daisy he just didn't get on his own title back in the day Mario saving Daisy it's not true

  15. Why does Super MARIO Bros 2 get so little love. It’s was not only far and away my fav but also brought us so many thing that carried on in to all the rest of the games

  16. ummm but the poltergeist 4000 is in mario kart ds so the rest of the luigis mansions games should happen after mario kart ds

  17. Clearly, Super Mario Odyssey Must Come After Super Mario 3D World, Mostly Because Of Peach Rejecting Mario At The End. And If It Does Mean That, That Also Means That Super Mario Land Must Come After Super Mario Odyssey.

  18. If Mario isnt the same as the Mario in Donkey Kong, then that slightly justifies him in your other video of how Mario is a horrible person. While he’s still a terrible person, he at least doesn’t have any of his crimes against DK

  19. You know how link never truly dies he response with his love of his life because of her magic in the legends of Zelda book at the end of the book as a manga

  20. Part 2: Mario vs DK series, Super Mario Odyssey, Mario Bros U deluxe, Donkey Kong Country, and the spinoff games (karts, parties, etc.)
    Don't say it's not possible, because you did the Zelda timeline.

  21. Maybe Mario is sociopath because Luigi stole his GF and he expresses it with ANGER. Destroying worms and toads, abusing Yoshis, BECAUSE Yoshis brought both Mario AND Luigi. I mean he punches them so he expresses that he is angry at them for bringing Luigi (because he hates him). Well Yeah he is psycho.

  22. I think new super Luigi U is cannon and was placed after the Mario u version and at the same time as Super Mario land, while he was saving Daisy

  23. Wouldn’t super Mario sunshine come directly after super Mario world? At the end it says that Mario peach and the toads are gonna take a vacation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *